Chapter 3
Part One: Six years earlier
"I slept with Seth."
"You WHAT?" Kay's friend Micah almost dropped the ice cream cone she was holding, and her jaw practically fell to the ground.
They were sitting on the grass in a public park; around them were families, groups of students and smooching couples, all enjoying the sunny spring afternoon.
Micah looked unsure of whether to be shocked or excited. "When? How? Why? And what the fuck, Kay?"
Kay smirked sheepishly at her own ice cream. "Last night." She shrugged. "It just… happened."
"Uh huh", Micah said with a scoff. "Right."
"Really! I didn't mean to do it." Seeing the alarmed look on her friend's face, she quickly clarified: "I mean, I wanted to, we both did. It simply wasn't planned."
Micah gave her a lazy smirk. "You just accidentally fell on top of him?"
With a laugh, Kay rolled her eyes. "We were at Glow and then his car conked out. So I invited him to crash at my place."
Now Micah rolled her eyes as well.
Kay gave her a look. "What?"
"So much for 'It wasn’t planned'."
"But it really wasn't!" Kay protested. "I don't know what happened, Micah, we suddenly… wanted each other."
Her friend lent her a telling look. "You didn't ‘suddenly’ want each other. He's always had the hots for you."
Kay averted her eyes, trying not to smile. "Oh please."
"What I really want to know is: Why? Why would you sleep with Pretty Boy? Doesn't he have a girlfriend?"
Kay scowled at her. She hated when Micah called him that. Sure, Seth was good looking – he even was what one would have called 'a beautiful man'. But obviously naming him 'Pretty Boy' was not a compliment on Micah's side. She didn't know Seth well and somehow had never really warmed up to him. Not that she had ever directly said so, but Kay suspected she didn't get what Kay saw in him as a person. From the moment Kay had introduced him to her at a party, Micah had immediately categorized Seth. Guys who looked like that couldn't be cool and multi-layered – Micah’s theory. The fact that Kay knew him much better and could attest for the theory not applying here hadn't been able to sway Micah in her preconception. That was Micah for you – quick to judge and hard to bring around.
"No, he doesn't have a girlfriend." Kay told her, not able to withhold the annoyance from her tone. "And will you stop calling him that? It's offending me."
At that, Micah laughed out loud. "It's offending you?"
Kay rolled her eyes, snorting. "And unfair to him, obviously. But you're implying I'm not a good judge of character. Do you seriously still think I would be such close friends with Seth if he was some shallow bore?"
"Girl, come on." Micah put her hand on Kay's knee. "I never said that. He's obviously a nice guy. Him and I just don't vibe well, that's all."
"You are the one not vibing", Kay corrected her, holding up a finger. "Seth's got nothing to do with it."
Micah sighed. "Look Dude, can we not argue about this? 'Cause I really, desperately want to fucking hear all the details already."
Kay huffed. Normally, she wouldn't have let this go. But right now, the part of her that needed to process last night was stronger. She took a deliberate, long lick of her yogurt ice cream, then intensely looked at her friend. "It was the best sex of my life."