Terms and Specific Conditions🍷🙄🕯️

Penelope had made the mistake of opening wine before Joseph arrived.

Not a ruinous mistake. Not a life-altering one. More of a small tactical error with medium-sized consequences.

By the time he got there, she was in the kitchen in socks, stirring a pan of something tomato-based with the serene confidence of a woman who had done exactly enough prep to become dangerous.

Joseph let himself in, dropped his keys on the table by the door, and looked around her apartment with the expression he always wore when entering any space she had personally arranged.

Not disapproval, exactly.

Just the weary recognition of a man who had known her too long.

“Well,” he said, taking in the candles, the playlist, the suspiciously nice napkins. “This looks normal.”

Penelope leaned on the spoon. “You’re obsessed with me.”

“I’m alarmed by effort.”

“It’s called hosting.”

“It’s called staging.”

She rolled her eyes and went back to the stove. Joseph wandered into the kitchen, nudged her aside with his hip so he could reach the wineglasses, poured himself one without asking, and looked into the simmering pan.

“What is it?”

“Pasta.”

“That is sauce.”

“The pasta comes later.”

He stole the spoon from her hand long enough to inspect the sauce, handed it back, and took a sip of wine.

“Comforting to know your overconfidence remains intact.”

Joseph was ten years older than her, which meant he had spent most of his adult life speaking to her like she was a bright but lightly unhousebroken animal he had, for reasons unclear even to himself, become extremely fond of. He was funny in the driest possible way, never in a rush, always looking faintly inconvenienced by everyone else’s feelings. It made him excellent company if you understood him and borderline criminal if you didn’t.

Penelope understood him.

Usually.

Tonight she was also a little bit buzzed, which meant she was finding him both extra funny and mildly persecutory.

He leaned against the counter and looked at her for a beat too long.

“What?”

“You’re twitchy.”

“I’m cooking.”

“You’ve checked your phone four times in three minutes.”

“I’m waiting for the pasta.”

“The pasta is not texting you back.”

She gave him a filthy look and topped up her wine.

Joseph watched this in silence, swirling his own glass thoughtfully.

Then the buzzer went.

Penelope froze, wooden spoon suspended mid-stir.

Joseph’s eyes moved from her face to the candles, to the wine, to the little involuntary smile she was already trying and failing to suppress.

She set her glass down and straightened, smoothing absolutely nothing over her jeans.

Joseph watched all of it in silence.

She pointed at him. “Don’t.”

He said nothing.

Which was worse.

She was already heading for the door when she turned back, smiling at him like, I dare you.

Then she opened it.

Jack was there in the hallway in a navy sweater and dark jeans, one hand on the push rim, the other steadying a white bakery box on his lap.

Penelope smiled at him, bright and automatic, then stepped aside so he could come in.

Jack rolled over the threshold easily, and she took the box from his lap without asking.

When she turned back toward the kitchen, she was still smiling—sweetly now, almost innocently, which was how Joseph knew she was absolutely full of shit.

He looked at Jack.

At the chair.

Back to Jack.

Then at Penelope.

“Penelope,” he sighed. “Have you ever once in your life heard of subtlety?”

Jack barked a laugh.

Joseph gave Penelope’s upper arm a smug little tap as he passed, like, exactly.

Penelope, without missing a beat, said, “Absolutely not.”

“Thought not,” Joseph said.

Jack looked between them. “Should I come back in five minutes or is this the show?”

“This is the show,” Joseph said.

“No,” Penelope said at the same time. “Come in.”

Jack rolled farther into the apartment, still smiling to himself.

Penelope set the box on the counter and opened it. “He brought tiny pies.”

Joseph glanced over. “Strong opening.”

He shrugged. “I didn’t want to show up empty-handed.”

“See?” Joseph said to Penelope. “That’s called functioning in society.”

“I function beautifully in society.”

Joseph took a sip of wine. “You once stole a neighbor’s license plate to steam the registration sticker off over a pot of boiling water because you said the government had already taken enough from you.”

“That was a victimless administrative adjustment.”

Jack, to Joseph: “That tracks.”

Penelope turned to him, fork in hand. “Wow. No hesitation at all.”

“I know you,” Jack said.

Joseph snorted into his wine.

That was the thing about Jack. He could walk into a room full of her family’s very specific nonsense and somehow not stiffen up around it. He didn’t overperform charm. He didn’t retreat. He just met the energy where it was and nudged it slightly funnier.

Penelope felt inappropriately pleased with herself, as if she had handcrafted him in a workshop and not merely invited him to dinner like a normal person.

She brought the pasta to the table, and dinner got underway with only moderate damage.

Joseph was in excellent form, which was dangerous.

He asked Jack what he did, and Jack explained just enough about work to be polite before turning the rest into a joke about attending meetings where grown adults used the phrase actionable visibility without shame. Joseph liked that immediately.

“Oh, good,” he said, setting down his fork. “So you translate nonsense for a living.”

“More or less.”

“And then you met Penelope and thought, ‘Yes. That. More of that.’”

Jack laughed. “Yeah, pretty much.”

Joseph looked at Jack over his glass. “So is this a head injury situation on your end or just bad instincts?”

Penelope’s fork stopped halfway to her mouth. “I’m sitting right here.”

“I know,” Joseph said.

Jack glanced at her, amused. “Bad instincts, mostly.”

Penelope barked out a laugh and set her fork down. “Wow. Okay.”

A few minutes later, Joseph leaned back in his chair and looked between the two of them with the kind of calm directness that made Penelope instantly suspicious.

There was a beat.

Then Joseph said, “So… do you ever, like—” He made a loose little gesture with one hand. “You know. In the chair?”

Jack choked on his wine, setting the glass down harder than intended.

Penelope didn’t even blink.

“Oh, constantly.”

Jack’s head snapped toward her so fast he rocked the chair a fraction.

She just looked back at him, smiling to herself like she was very pleased with the shot placement.

Joseph stared at her for half a second, then leaned back with a grin—sharp and almost devilish, like this was the answer he’d been hoping for.

“Amazing.”

Jack looked between them, still recovering. “Oh, you two are actually deranged.”

Penelope folded her arms. “He’s trying to see if you’ll flinch.”

Joseph pointed at her with his wine glass. “She’s trying to see if I will.”

Jack laughed, properly now, looking between them like he’d rolled into some highly specific sibling blood sport and accidentally become part of it.

Penelope took a sip of wine, deeply satisfied with herself.

Joseph clocked that too, obviously.

“God,” he said. “You really did give yourself a point for that.”

She smiled into her glass. “I don’t know what you mean.”

“That’s because you’ve never been honest a day in your life.”

“I’m one of the most honest people I know.”

“That says more about your social circle than it does about you.”

Jack made a low sound that was almost a laugh and almost a cough, still recovering.

Dinner recovered too, somehow.

They moved on to safer topics: their insane family, their general inability to behave like civilized humans, and the time Joseph had once smuggled Penelope into a fetish club in Berlin when she was fifteen.

Jack looked up. “I’m sorry, what?”

Penelope pointed her fork at Joseph. “Thank you. He said smuggled like I was contraband.”

“You were fifteen,” Joseph said. “You were, by definition, illegal.”

“I looked older.”

“You looked like a problem in lip gloss.”

Jack was already laughing.

Penelope turned to him. “In my defense, he brought me.”

Joseph gave him a tired look over the rim of his glass. “Have you met her? Brought is also generous. She attached herself to my social life like a curse.”

“That is not true.”

“It is deeply true.”

Penelope sat back in her chair with the lofty dignity of someone who had done absolutely nothing dignified in this story so far. “He was going out in Berlin, I was fifteen, and I had excellent judgment.”

Joseph barked a laugh. “You had the judgment of a raccoon in a gas leak.”

Jack looked between them. “You actually took her to a fetish club.”

Joseph pointed at Penelope with his fork. “I did not take her to a fetish club. I made the catastrophic mistake of believing her when she said—and I quote—‘I’ll be cool.’”

“I was cool.”

Joseph looked at Jack. “She was doing poppers twenty minutes in.”

Jack nearly inhaled his drink. “Jesus Christ.”

“With alarming confidence,” Joseph said. “No hesitation. Full commitment. Like she was returning to a former profession.”

Penelope waved a hand. “I was very mature for my age.”

“You were in a silver top from H&M and one hoop earring because you’d already lost the other one in the taxi.”

Jack dropped his head into one hand, laughing.

Penelope pointed accusingly across the table. “You let me talk to that man in mesh.”

Joseph stared at her. “That man in mesh was named Klaus and he was trying to sell you ketamine.”

“He was very kind.”

“He was not kind,” Joseph said. “He was German and on ketamine.”

Jack made a noise that was somewhere between a cough and a laugh and looked at Joseph like he was trying to decide whether he was serious.

Joseph looked back at him, perfectly calm.

“I found her in a corner doing poppers with the expression of a woman discovering religion.”

Penelope put a hand to her chest. “That is not how I’d describe it.”

“That is because you lack self-awareness.”

“I had some.”

“You had none. You had glitter on your collarbone and the confidence of a much worse person.”

Jack was laughing openly now, shoulders shaking, one hand braced lightly on the wheel beside him.

Penelope looked at him and, traitorously, started laughing too.

“It was one time,” she said.

Joseph turned to Jack. “This is what I’m saying. People meet her now and think, wow, chaotic adult woman. They do not appreciate that she was also an insane child.”

“I was not an insane child.”

Joseph looked at him. “She stole our grandmother’s wig once.”

Penelope slapped a hand over her face. “Oh my God.”

Jack blinked. “I’m sorry?”

“She had alopecia,” Joseph said.

Jack stared at Penelope. “Why would you do that?”

Penelope groaned into her hand. “I was four. I thought it was haunted.”

Joseph took a sip of wine. “You see the issue.”

Jack nodded, still visibly recovering. “This is pretty representative, yeah.”

“She does seem to prefer all experiences at maximum intensity,” Joseph said.

“That is because I’m alive,” Penelope shot back.

“That is because you’ve never once met an inside thought you couldn’t outsource.”

Jack laughed into his drink again.

Joseph pointed at him. “See? That. You’re encouraging her.”

“I don’t think this is my fault.”

“Oh, no,” Joseph said. “This was all there before you. But you do seem to have a stabilizing effect that I find deeply suspicious.”

Penelope smiled despite herself, reaching for the wine bottle.

Joseph caught it, of course.

He looked between them, took a sip of wine, and said, “Right, well. It does make sense.”

“What does?” Penelope asked too quickly.

Joseph ignored her and addressed Jack.

“She’s never liked anything straightforward in her life. A normal boyfriend would have worried me more.”

Joseph had taken in the whole picture and folded it into one dry sentence like it was obvious.

Penelope went still for half a second, her hand frozen on her glass.

Jack gave a quiet huff of laughter. “Jesus,” he said softly. Then: “That’s one way to put it.”

“What?” Joseph said, registering Penelope’s face. “Oh, don’t be so dramatic.” He turned to Jack. “You’re lovely. Not exactly conventional, obviously, but then neither is she. That’s clearly the system.”

A laugh punched out of Penelope—sharp and surprised and almost relieved.

She covered it with a drink, but the smile stayed.

Joseph glanced at her and said, “Don’t get emotional. It doesn’t suit you.”

“I’m not emotional.”

“You’re practically glowing.”

Jack looked at her then, and the warmth that moved into his expression was so immediate and unguarded she wanted to throw a plate at both men for perceiving things.

Joseph caught that too.

“Jesus Christ,” he said, not unkindly. “Look at the two of you. Revolting.”

Penelope pointed at him with her fork. “Stop observing.”

“I would,” he said, “but you make it impossible.”

After dinner they opened the box, and Joseph became suspiciously tender about the tiny pies.

“It’s the miniature aspect,” he said, holding one up to examine it. “Tiny versions of normal things make me feel protective.”

“That is one of the gayest things you’ve ever said,” Penelope said.

“And yet completely true.”

Jack took one and nodded. “I actually get it.”

Joseph made a broad, exasperated gesture at him, directed squarely at Penelope. “Thank you. Finally.”

Jack helped clear, and Penelope kept trying to intercept plates and glasses before anyone could fully commit to carrying them. Joseph finally set down what he was holding and looked at her.

“Penelope, if you fuss at him one more time, I’m putting you outside.”

“I am not fussing.”

“You are hovering.”

“I’m hosting.”

Jack looked at Joseph. “This does seem to have activated something in her.”

“Of course it has,” Joseph said. “She’s physically incapable of liking anyone in a normal way.”

Penelope put the plates in the sink with more force than necessary. “I’m getting a complex.”

“You came with one,” Joseph said, drying his hands.

Jack grinned.

And that was the whole night, really.

That easy, stupid rhythm.

Joseph needling. Jack rolling with it. Penelope trying to maintain some scrap of dignity and failing almost instantly every time.

When Jack finally said he should head out, Joseph stood too, carrying his empty glass to the sink.

“Well, this is upsetting,” Joseph said. “You’re very easy to like. I was prepared for far more reasons to object, frankly.”

“High praise,” Jack said.

Penelope huffed. “It is from him.”

Joseph ignored her. “You seem to have taken her measure quite quickly. Most people need a week and a lie down.”

Jack glanced at Penelope, amused.

At the door, Penelope walked him out.

He paused in the hallway and looked at her face for one second too long.

“You okay?” he said quietly.

She leaned against the doorframe and let out a breath through her nose. “That depends. How red was your face during the chair conversation.”

He laughed. “Bad.”

“Cool.”

“But your brother’s funny.”

“He’s incredibly annoying.”

“You people show affection in an alarming way.”

She huffed a laugh. “He likes you.”

Jack’s expression shifted, softening just slightly.

“That’s terrifying, actually,” he said.

She grabbed his hand when he turned to go. Just a quick squeeze. Casual enough to survive if someone saw. Not casual at all, really.

He looked down at her hand, then back up at her face.

“Subtle.”

She smiled despite herself. “Get out.”

He did, still grinning.

When she shut the door and went back inside, Joseph was rinsing glasses in the kitchen.

He didn’t turn around when he said, “He’s good.”

Penelope stopped in the doorway.

“Yeah,” she said.

Joseph dried his hands, glanced over, and gave her one of those infuriatingly clear-eyed older-brother looks.

Then, deadpan as ever:

“Still. ‘Oh, constantly’ was one of the worst things I’ve ever seen.”

Penelope laughed and threw a tea towel at his head.

He caught it one-handed.